WASHINGTON POST   Families... And So On: Gay Couples and Adoption

Washington Post, July 24, 2001
1150 15th Street NW, Washington, DC, 20071
(E-Mail: letterstoed@washpost.com )( http://washingtonpost.com/ )
http://discuss.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/zforum/01/salmon0724.htm
Families... And So On:
Gay Couples and Adoption

With Jacqueline L. Salmon,
Washington Post Staff Writer

Join Post Metro reporter Jacqui Salmon and Jon and Michael Galluccio, authors of "An American Family." In the book, the gay couple chronicle their fight in New Jersey to adopt their HIV-positive infant foster son. Their court challenge helped rewrite New Jersey law to allow joint adoption by unmarried couples. They now have three adopted children and one grandchild.

Families...and So On, hosted by Washington Post families reporter Jacqueline L. Salmon, is a free-ranging and freewheeling look at the American family. This is the place to talk about the burning issues facing the 21st century family.

The transcript follows.

Jacqui Salmon: Hello Jon and Michael and welcome to "Families...and so on." You have an amazing story. What prompted you both to decide to write a book about your experience? Did you decide after New Jersey decided to lift its ban on joint adoptions by unmarried couples or earlier in the process?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: It was after -- when we received the media attention from winning. People from all over the world were writing to us and sharing with us. We started simply with a newsletter, and people said 'hey this really should be a book.'

Jacqui Salmon: Tell us about your decision to fight the state in order to jointly adopt Adam. By doing that, did you risk losing Adam completely? You were Adam's foster parents at that point, but the state could have easily yanked him from your home.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: There was always that option. However, once we went public and filed our case, the public outcry against the state of New Jersey for not allowing our joint adoption was so great and so favorable that we stopped thinking that the state would be able to take Adam away.

Jacqui Salmon: To get all of you caught up on this case, in their book, the Galluccios write that they decided to refuse New Jersey's offer that Michael (the breadwinner in the family) should adopt the sick infant they had been caring for. They opted to challenge the state in court for the ability to jointly adopt Adam together. To make a long story short, they won and, in fact, New Jersey became one of the first states in the country to permit unmarried couples to adopt children. Along with Adam, the couple now has a daughter Madison, whom they adopted as an infant, and a daughter Rosa, Madison's half-sister who joined the family a bit later.

Jacqui Salmon: How are your children doing? Your son Adam is about 6 years old now, right? And Madison, your daughter, is how old?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Adam will be 6 in September and still somehwat frozen as a two-year-old in the mind of the public! He is doing wonderfully. He is slightly learning disabled, but we're addressing that. Other than that, he's phenomenally healthy. Madison is great. She's had no lingering effects of the drugs from her mother. She'll be five in December. And our daughter Rosa is now 18 (we finalized her adoption when she was 17 and 8 months pregnant). Now we have an eight-month-old grandaughter, Maryanna, in our house.

Jacqui Salmon: Wow, you've got a houseful.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: It's great. It's also semi-insane, but just like most American families.

Jacqui Salmon: How did you decide who was going to be the at-home parent? Jon has been doing it from the beginning. In your book, you talk about your decision that you wanted a parent at home when you took children into your house.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Jon: I'm the actor, which meant I wasn't brining home a lot of bacon! It just made sense financially. Michael was jealous at first, but if you ask him now, he got the better deal. Being an at-home parent is the hardest job in the world.

Jacqui Salmon: Are you also caring for your granddaughter?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: No, Jon doesn't. Our granddaughter goes to the day-care center where Rosa works. She graduated from high school in June.

Jacqui Salmon: Sounds like you ended up facing a situation that many parents of teenagers have had to come to grips with -- dealing with a pregnant teen.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Our first reaction was "what is everyone going to say?" It's sort of like coming out when you're gay! But after going through everything and meeting with family therapists and so on, we decided that unconditional love is unconditional love and that we would support her because she wanted this baby. However, SHE was going to have the baby, not us. We didn't want to raise another baby ourselves. Rosa, however, has risen wonderfully to the occasion. As far as teenage mothers go, she's tops.

Jacqui Salmon: So are you both still vegetarians? In the book you tell the story of becoming vegetarians because that diet was the healthiest for Adam -- even though you were both enthusiastic meat eaters. How's it going?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Well, Jon tends to, when Adam's not in sight -- have a cheeseburger or two. Michael is much more strict with the vegetarian regime. If we're out and the only choice is meat, Jon doesn't go out of his way. Michael does, however, go out of his way to get a vegetarian meal.

MH in Md.: Do you feel that adoptions should be allowed/encouraged by unmarried heterosexual couples, since that position might increase public sympathy towards adoptions by gay couples, or do you feel that it's superfluous, since heterosexual couples have no barriers to getting married and being considered? I know it shouldn't be a political football, but unfortunately it can be. Bravo on your perserverance and courage to beat a path. Whether you meant to or not, you've made it easier for others.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We believe a marriage license helps the stability of a family. But it doesn't undermine the ability of a couple to be loving, caring parents just because they're not married. In New Jersey, the new policy permitting unmarried couples to adopt applies to heterosexual couples as well as gay couples. But in our case, of course, we couldn't get married because we were gay.

Jacqui Salmon: Where does the issue of joint adoption by unmarried couples stand elsewhere in the country? I believe there is a court case in Florida challenging that state's ban on such joint adoptions that may end up in federal court.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Florida bans gays and lesbians from adopting and, yes, it's being challenged in court. There are actually only three other states that, like New Jersey, have a policy allowing a joint adoption by gay couples. Those states are Connecticut, New Hampshire and California. However, in some states, adoption law is done county-by-county or even judge-by-judge. In some areas, then, gay adoptions are allowed, but it's not state policy.

Centreville, Va.: How long were you two together before you decided to adopt?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We didn't discuss having children until we were together for over 12 years. We've now been together for 19 and a half years. But from the first discussion until now, we've managed three children and a grandchild!

Warsaw, Poland: Honestly, I have trouble imagining why anyone would object to this issue. A child who would not have a home otherwise is being given a home by a set of people who love him/her. Does anything much really matter? Seems to be a bit of a definitive non-issue.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Thanks for your comments. By the way, it's amazing how many people in Poland are a aware of our case. We see a lot of papers in Poland that have written stories about us.

Washington, D.C.: What are your hopes for your children? Considering homosexuality leaves you subject to discrimination (homosexuality being somewhat controllable in comparison to race), do you want them to be among the "norm" in regard to sexuality? Avoiding some potential hardships?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We want our children to be happy and comfortable with whomever they are. Straight, gay, left-handed,whatever, we want them to be filled with enough self-respect to hold their heads high and be proud of who they are.

Georgia: I think it is really wonderful when people want children -- and I think it is even doubly wonderful when the parents can take care of a child better than their birth parents -- even if those parents are gay. With that said -- I am still against gay adoptions. I think the main point that I can't get past is that these gay parents are showing their kids that the other sex is not valuable in any way. The women are showing that they don't need a man and the men are showing they don't need a woman. I believe both would be confusing and destructive to the child. How do you get around those issues in a gay adoption?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Well, we don't live in a gay vaccuum! We live on a street with neighbors. And our parents are very much involved in our family life, so our children certainly see the worth of women being equal to that of men. They also see more heterosexual relationships than homosexual relationships -- by far! We think our children understand better than many people the value of love. When Madison plays, she's 'mommy.' She's certainly not confused. We think our kids are fortunate. From the beginning, they get to see the world without prejudice. And, hopefully, they won't struggle with the internalized homophobia that most of us -- gay or straight -- still suffer from in this country.

Washington, D.C.: Do you feel it was more difficult trying to second parent adopt when neither of you were the child's biological parent? Also, do you know of any resources available to other gays and lesbians that could inform them as to the adoption policy in states other than NJ?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: www.familypride.org. That's probably the most comprehensive resource out there now. As for your first question, I think there are two separate issues here, and our issue of joint adoption of Adam can't be compared to second-parenting a biological child.

Centreville, Va.: Do you think your children will be subjected to any ridicule as a result of having gay parents? What have/will you do to prepare them for any?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Again, hopefully we'll raise them with enough self respect to understand that the ridicule has nothing to do with them. Kids are picked on for lots of reasons -- Jon was picked on for being short, and Michael was picked on for being fat and Italian. At least our kids will know what they're being picked up for, if they are, indeed, picked on. Kids can be cruel, but it's their PARENTS who teach them that. Plano, Texas: Haven't the studies that have been done shown that gay couples that adopt are actually far better parents than the average straight couple? That may be partly because its so hard to become parents.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: If there are some studies that say that, we really like them! A comprehensive English study, in fact, came to that conclusion. And we think there's some merit to it. Gays have to work hard to become parents. We have to think about how we're going to become parents, and when and where and sometimes we have to take on the whole legal system to do it.

Vienna, Va.: Jon and Michael, all of these questions on talk shows about gay couples, gay marriages, and gay adoption may soon be a moot point because a proposed Constitutionnal amendment is in the works (we're talking Federal constitution here, not just a state one), that will recognize marriage ANYWHERE IN THE UNITED STATES as between ONE male and ONE female. There is an enormous amount of support for this and it will probably pass the required 38 states. If and when that happens, all state laws recognizing and permitting non-traditional marriages and adoption will be invalid. If you won your case in New Jersey, enjoy it while it lasts. I'm not saying this as a gay-basher, bigot, or anything else...just being realistic and objective.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Well, many people in this country once thought that Americans would never regain the right to drink again back in the '20s when Prohibition was passed. In other words, we don't feel that there are enough people in this country to support a Consitutional amendment that would create a second class of citizenship. In fact, a few countries have already given gay and lesbian couples marriage rights. Vermont now has 'civil unions' for gays and lesbians. And these policies haven't broken down the family. They have just strengthened gay and lesbian families.

Washington, D.C.: Question for Jacqui -- My partner and I (two men) have begun the process of adoption. We are going through public, not private adoption. We have been told that we must be foster parents first before the we will have the opportunity to adopt. That can be anywhere from 6 months to a few years, I suspect. Do you think this is just a ruse for DC to shore up a shockingly low number of potential foster parents in the city?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: States are trying to do everything they can to find more foster familes. We have 500,000 foster children in this country. We are in a state of crisis in this country in that respect. There aren't enough foster parents for the children who need them. We don't think that states can really get away with the type of 'game-playing' you describe.

Jacqui Salmon: In fact, I've interviewed gay couples in the District who have adopted children through public adoptions in that jurisdiction, so I don't think it should be a problem. However, I can look up the info and give you a fuller answer later, if you wish. Just send me an email via salmonj@washpost.com

Bethesda, Md.: What do your children call you? And did the names evolve, or did you two decide up front what they would be?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We decided upfront that Jon would be 'daddy' and that Michael would be 'father.' 'Father' sounds kind of stuffy, but in reality there is nothing sweeter once they've mastered the word. But it certainly has evolved -- from "dadoo' to 'dadder' to 'fadder' to 'father.' And now they call Michael 'Fathie." We guess they're on an 'ie' kick right now.

Washington, D.C.: What do you feel are some of the biggest obstacles facing same-sex couples for adopting children? What issues do you feel that could be improved in order for gay/lesbian couples to adopt without much trouble?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We believe the biggest obstacles lie within ourselves -- and how much of the homophobia that we've bought into. We had to surmount those obstacles as well -- that having children wasn't right, that gay couples shouldn't have children and all those other issues. Everything that we've talked about today, we had to surmount before we were ready to adopt. The biggest improvement that would make it easier for gay/lesbians to adopt would be simply giving us the right to marry! It would force people to recognize us as equal and not as 'less than.' The truth is that we ARE equal and not 'less than.'

Washington, D.C.: First off, as a former resident of NJ, I applaud you. I, myself, am adopted and was raised in a straight household but turned out gay. I was raised by two loving parents who have shown me unconditional love. I may be the biological product of someone else but I know who my parents are. Gays and lesbians do not go into parenting lightly. It is done with the best of intentions and the greatest of love. Knowing that there are children out there to be adopted, I wish all states would look at just how "normal" gay parents are and allow gay and lesbian couples to adopt.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Thanks. We agree, whole-heartedly. In fact, Jon is an adoptee himself, so he knows exactly where you're coming from.

Jacqui Salmon: In fact, Jon, a very compelling aspect of your book was your search for your own biological mother. How did that come out?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Through jealousy! That emotion was probably first because Adam received all sorts of information about his biological family -- such as medical histories of his birth mother, her mother, an aunt, etc. The lack of a medical history, for me, had always been an issue. And becoming Adam's father (my adoptive father died when I was 10), made it even more important. And so I searched for my biological mother, and I found her. It's been a difficult process -- emotionally and psychologically, but beautiful nonetheless -- with my birth mother. But not so with my birth father. But, the bottom line is, I now have my family medical history.

Reston, Va.: For the person from Georgia who thinks that children who have two men as parents will think that women aren't valuable, what about kids whose parents are both Asian American? Will they think that other races aren't valuable? Should every child have to be raised by a couple with 2 different sexes, races, religions, political affiliations, etc? I don't think so. I think this gay couple has a great attitude, and as they point out, they aren't raising their kids in a vacuum. If kids are exposed to all kinds of people and taught to respect them all, it won't be a problem.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Thanks! We like you!

Springfield, Va.: I wish I had parents like you guys when I was growing up. THANKS for having the courage to speak out and be yourselves. I can only hope that others follow. Do you have any regrets thus far (about being in the public eye and such)?

Jon and Michael Galluccio: The pressure can get intense sometimes. But the rewards and gifts that we've received from being a public family outweigh any of the negatives. Knowing that there may be another teenager out there who doesn't kill himself because he's gay is enough inspiration to stay out there for a lonnnnggg time. And we get that feedback a lot.

Washington, D.C.: As a 27-year-old (better late than never!!) woman who just came out, I want to thank you for your example. I was terrified of being gay my whole life, and your beautiful family helps to alleviate some of the stigma that kept me from being who I am for so long. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Your kids are lucky to have such accepting and loving parents.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: You're going to make Jon cry....thanks.

Potomac Falls, Md.: I applaud you both! My partner and I have a 2 year old son (she birthed) and I am due with his sister in 6 weeks! We are both professionals, own a wonderful home in suburbia, and live a very "normal" life. We do not feel we are actively discriminated against in any way. Our parents still fear that for us and our children, but we believe that if we conduct ourselves appropriately, people around us will treat us (and our children) fairly. More people need to step forward and tell their stories so that mainstream America realize that we're OK with our lives...and they should be too!
Regarding the issue of "the other sex," our best friends include heterosexual males. We don't dislike them, and we engage frequently with them to ensure our children have positive male influences. I am sure that Jon and Michael do the same thing!

Jon and Michael Galluccio: We think that's the point we're making. In this era of American history, with mass communication and the growth of the Internet and so on, there are more people willing to step forward and come out and share their story with their churches, their Rotary Clubs...their world.
But when we speak at colleges around the country, we can still have hundreds of college students come up and say "I've never seen or talked to an openly gay couple before." So there is still a way to go.

Hyattsville, Md.: Hi, Jon and Michael. Your story has meant a lot to my partner and me, and we are planning to have a baby in the near future. My question is whether you think that NJ is a good state for gay parents and whether there are any areas of the state that are more gay-friendly than others.

Jon and Michael Galluccio: Well, we've heard that northern NJ (where we live) seems to be more liberal and more supportive! But, also, we know that throughout the country, there are communities in every state where a family like ours can find love and support and nurturing.
If you want more information about our family, you can go to our Web site, galluccio.com. You can also email us from that site, and we post photos of our family. But if you email us, be patient. We may take a long time to get back to you, but we do respond to everyone.

Jacqui Salmon: Thanks to the Galluccios and thanks to you out there for your thoughtful questions, (including the ones that made it clear that you disapprove of the Galluccios' family life). Once again, you've earned my admiration for thinking critically and deeply about the disparate lives of families in our society. Coming up next week is a discussion on researching your family's geneology online. I've got a great guest who is a veritable encyclopedia on the topic, so send in your questions early. You can usually post them several days before the chat.